PhD, University Malaya · Impact Investing & Sustainable Finance

Home / Publications

Working paper

From Measuring Impact to Managing It: A Life-Cycle Framework for Impact Investing Accountability

Impact data is too often used to prove performance to outside audiences rather than to improve it. This article proposes a five-stage framework that ties impact evidence to real decisions, and sets out six testable propositions on when impact information genuinely changes decisions.

Dr. Chia Shee Tong Tom · University Malaya

Abstract

Impact investing combines an explicit intention to generate social or environmental benefit with the pursuit of financial returns. Yet impact data can serve mainly to demonstrate performance to external audiences, leaving less attention for how evidence changes investment decisions and improves outcomes.

This conceptual article develops a life-cycle framework that connects impact measurement to management and accountability across five stages. It distinguishes the measurement of enterprise outcomes from the contribution of investor capital and engagement, and proposes that indicators should be selected for decision relevance, proportionality, stakeholder legitimacy, and evidential strength. Six propositions identify conditions under which impact information is more likely to influence investor–investee decisions and support learning.

The five-stage life cycle

Impact evidence is tied to real decisions at every stage — from setting the mandate through to exit.

  1. 01 Mandate & strategy Define the change the capital is meant to achieve.
  2. 02 Screening & due diligence Test each investment’s impact thesis before committing.
  3. 03 Structuring Align terms, incentives and reporting with outcomes.
  4. 04 Active ownership & monitoring Use evidence to adapt strategy and operations.
  5. 05 Exit & portfolio learning Carry lessons forward into the next mandate.

Six evidence principles

  1. Decision relevance
  2. Proportionality
  3. Stakeholder legitimacy
  4. Contribution discipline
  5. Balanced evidence
  6. Learning-linked accountability

Key insights

  • Measure to improve, not only to prove: evidence should change what investors and investees do next.
  • Enterprise outcomes are not the same as investor contribution; credible claims keep the two apart.
  • The article is conceptual: it proposes testable propositions rather than reporting new primary data.
First page of the working paper “From Measuring Impact to Managing It”

14 pages · PDF

Details

Type

Conceptual article

Status

Working paper (preprint)

Year

2026

Length

14 pages

Affiliation

University Malaya

DOI

Pending

Cite this paper

Chia Shee Tong Tom. (2026). From measuring impact to managing it: A life-cycle framework for impact investing accountability [Working paper]. https://tomchia.com/publications/measuring-to-managing-impact/